Feedback form YouTube
In a previous post I put our short film on YouTube to get feedback and here's a selection of the feedback.
Online conversation records
19:02:53] Wannazzaki: .....>.>
[19:03:25] Wannazzaki: Oh gods that is fail
[19:03:32] Wannazzaki: that is hilariously bad acting fail
[19:03:39] SpartanLolrus: shush XD
[19:03:49] SpartanLolrus: the fight scenes need work
[19:04:03] SpartanLolrus: its just jumping back and forth
[19:05:05] Wannazzaki: yeah you need to actually land blows
[19:05:08] Wannazzaki: as peter Jackson said
[19:05:20] Wannazzaki: Pain lasts a week but this movie will last a life time
[19:05:33] SpartanLolrus: the music track fits, its subtle, slightly creepyish with a build up
[19:06:34] SpartanLolrus: Hm
[19:06:36] SpartanLolrus: five suggestions.
[19:06:45] SpartanLolrus: 1: use photoshop tools to add a muzzleflare to the pistol.
[19:07:00] SpartanLolrus: 2: have him have a blood packet to slap when he falls so you see some blood.
[19:07:20] SpartanLolrus: 3: work on expressions a bit, undead are wooden, yes, but they need a bit more inflection, tone and speech work.
[19:07:48] SpartanLolrus: 4: use a bit of lighting tinkering when the 'vampires' are on screen so they look a bit off coloured and pale.
[19:08:14] SpartanLolrus: 5: have a narrator who can enunciate clearly state something like 'I am X, this, is how it all happened' or some shit.
[19:08:40] SpartanLolrus: other then that, ive seen worse, its not a bad start by any means.
[19:13:09] Wannazzaki: Also needs a weapon
[19:13:12] Wannazzaki: like a metal pipe
[19:13:15] Wannazzaki: or a plank of wood
[19:13:25] Wannazzaki: pick it up, go nuts
Comments on YouTube
it's better than our film turned out :). the music fits it really well and the acting is actually pretty decent :), but tut tut smokings bad tom. (I would like to note here we did take precautions and at no point did it actully show anyone smokeing, the cigarettes where never lit, and we in no way promote smoking.)
WashYourJeans It's good. I enjoy it much.
The music fits nicely... could improve on the sound effects for the fight scene though =)
Lshellx3 Wow. this was reallyy good. I wanna knoe the ending though!! xD
GothicGirlOf1996 Firstly, I want to say congradulations on the excellent video!
Further, I simply adore the "Bite Me" Pun, I did indeed find myself laughing at that.
An absolutely spiffing creation.
Also, you claim that this is not yet completed, Karl-
I will hope to see the finished result, if this is the case. =)
(Amy Rebecca)
abijo1 love the part where karl says, then you will be destroyed lmao! proper good! luke makes me chuckle thoo xxxxxxx
xBlondeMomentsx omg guys thats sooo good, :) Well done, :) Love you all, Kirstie xxx
rommelandremus Wow that is ace - and goddam ya leavin it on tht cliffhanger!!! i must know why she just shot him !!! xx
Shadetta31 This is pretty gewd!
I like the atmospheric music.
One of the vampires probably had trouble seeing though, haha.
(It's Sally by the way, hi to all of you xD)
thomaswest my acting in this is terrible!! this is so embaressing XD
(im the main character btw)
8aliens It could be worse XD
sophiaathina @thomaswest haha ahhw you're so cute though :)
0x0MissPiggy0x0 hehe loved it... keep up the good work... !
Comments on FaceBook
Jo... xx:
its good
Julie Winder:
I've just watched your short film and was well impressed, you all did really well, it was funny watching it knowing that I know you and Kim. Great job to all of you.
velzz:
nice film!
roRAWR:
I have seen it (: it is really goood xx
topherlooks:
not gonna lie. I was crying because I was laughing so much.
From this feedback we got information on the good and bad points but I felt that some of the people saying its good with no say on what's good about it may have been saying it just because we know them. So I decided to ask some more critical people who more or less said the acting was bad, they didn't quite get the storyline, the script could have been better and the time changes where a little confusing, (it was also said that it had too many shots for a 5 minuet film making them feel like there being thrown about, however this wasn't noted much as more marks are given for using a greater number of shots).
After we got this feedback changes where made to the film to hopefully make it better. Among there where changes to the title, sound, editing/cuts, credits, and we added the sound of a phone call to the end of the film when the credits are on to make the story more complete.